I WAS JUST THINKIN'...
In This Section

Do We Need to Shift to Competency-based Professional Education?


Jun 19, 2018

Everyone knows that the current continuing education (CPE) model in the CPA profession is broken, and while there is a lot of discussion about the future of learning and how the model has to change, the only ones that I know who are making huge strides in enacting the changes is the Indiana CPA Society (INCPAS).



I was excited to be asked to be a part of the advisory board for their CPA Center of Excellence® (CPA COE)—their initiative to shift from hours-based CPE to competency-based CPE. Indiana is leading the United States in accepting the competency-based model, and has already modified its laws to allow competency-based credit, however they are in the middle of rule-making to implement the changes and this is proving harder than they expected.



How is Competency-based CPE Different from Hours-based CPE?



Hours-based CPE is generally earned from participating in instructor-led courses (in-person or via webinar) or by taking self-study courses for which the number of hours required to complete has been determined. Requirements vary from state to state, but in general, most CPAs are required to earn at least 40 hours of CPE each year to maintain our licenses.



The flaw in hours-based CPE is that while a person may participate in an instructor-led course, there is nothing that requires that the person actually learn anything from the course—they simply need to be physically present (not necessarily mentally present). In many courses and conferences, you can often see people doing other work, checking their email, or sometimes even sleeping.


 

This is because in-person courses assumes being present equals learning. So if the person teaching the course, or the organization hosting the course, doesn’t moderate the participants’ behavior then a person may be in the course, but not actually learning anything.



On the other hand, self-study courses, require that the person taking the course pass a quiz (usually multiple choice) to demonstrate that they’ve read the materials. While this does provide a means of measuring if the person actually read the materials, it actually just tests the person’s ability to recall or find information rather than apply or interpret it. (Note that the same challenge occurs in most academic learning environments as well.)



Then comes competency-based CPE, which then requires that a participant demonstrate that they are able to actually apply the information, demonstrate the skills, or exhibit the behaviors to earn credit for the course. While this sounds great, the ability to actually “test” this type of competency development is much more difficult and complex than simply administering a quiz.



Challenges with Competency-based Learning



The discussion during the CPA COE Advisory Board meeting surfaced some additional challenges with implementing competency-based learning:



  • Difficulty determining what is the “right answer.” A key aspect in testing the application of learning is that you can’t use close-ended questions, they must be open-ended an allow the person to demonstrate their understanding and ability to apply the learning. It was pointed out that if you take an open-ended question, and present it to four different experts in the field from which the question was derived, and you’d probably get four different answers—all of which may be right. By their nature, open-ended or reflective questions (those that ask a person to look at how they’ve seen a concept exhibited in their experiences) are difficult to grade.
  • Harder to design and grade. Some of difficulty in determining what is the right answer, could potentially be addressed with carefully design questions, but this is easier said than done. Because answers can vary greatly, this often means that they must be graded by a human—and not just any human, a human who can identify what the application of the learning looks like. As the complexity of the material gets higher, the capabilities of the grader also must be higher.
  • Higher cost to implement. From the previous bullets, you can see where developing competency-based learning is going to require higher competency (pun intended) in both instructional design and in the subject matter being taught. This results in a higher cost to attract a person with the right education, skills, or background to both design the course and grade the participants’ answers to the course assessments.


I’ve purposely kept the explanations above relatively simplified so as to not have to dive into a bunch of academic theory around learning, but there is a plethora of academic research around “assessment” (how to measure whether learning outcomes have been accomplished), much of which is actually inconclusive on the best way to measure learning and competency.



Should On-The-Job Learning Count Toward Competency?



One of the core values of the CPA profession is “Life-long Learning”. This means that we don’t just learn when we’re in the classroom, but that our careers and ability to deliver high quality services to our clients requires that we be life-long learners—learning and adapting on-the-job as new information becomes available and as the business environment changes.



One of the propositions posed by the INCPAS competency-based credit model is that CPAs should receive credit for on-the-job learning because it represents non-classroom learning and their ability to apply that learning to real-world situations. The discussion raised several points on this:



How do we assess this? The challenges around measuring the amount of actual learning, and who would measure that learning in an on-the-job situation again present themselves in this situation. If academics are still having a hard time performing these types of assessments well, how would a person’s supervisor or even an HR department be able to perform these assessments?


Is it really learning? The other big question is whether learning actually occurred. From a simple perspective, learning should represent an increase in a person’s knowledge or ability to do something. The first few times the learning is applied, there may be increased competency, but those gains are subject to the law of diminishing returns and some research has actually shown that after a certain point in time, competency actually decreases over time because someone that has been doing something for so long has a tendency to become more lax or overconfident in their execution of the competency.


The group didn’t really reach a conclusion on this, but I think that if we can identify the desired parameters and outcomes that demonstrate on-the-job learning, then we may be able to provide credit for on-the-job learning.



A Potential Way to Measure On-The-Job Competency Development



For example, if someone did research on a particular tax issue for a client, then the following parameters could be used:



The issue must be in an area where the person has not previously already demonstrated competency, or the issue must represent an increase in complexity or deeper understanding of the area.


The person must be able to describe or summarize the learning in a way where the learning creates additional explicit knowledge. For example, if they were researching a particular tax issue for a client, then they should be able to describe the key points of the related tax laws or regulations and how these would be applied to interpret the tax handing of a particular situation.


The person must be able to demonstrate repeated application of the learning. So in the example above, they would need to show how they applied the same learning to other tax returns.


The above is based on how I’ve determined if one of my staff has demonstrated their ability to perform the business analysis or project management work that we do well, but I’ve used a tax example above to make it more generally understandable to CPAs.



Arguments Against the Move to a Competency-based CPE Model



One of the questions that arose during the discussion was “are we trying to fix something that isn’t broken?”. Part of the justification to change to competency-based CPE is because it would stop the “cheaters” who are signing up for the in-person learning but doing other work or sleeping through a class. But some of the group felt that cheaters will always find a way to cheat, and someone shared a statistic that the number of people actually cheating the system is actually quite low. So would the changes actually stop the cheaters?



Another way to address the issue is to make the in-person courses more interactive requiring the person to actually participate in the learning. Research around learning also shows that incorporating application or an experiential element into a course increases a person’ retention of what was taught. So this is something that I think should be done anyway to improve the quality of classes being offered. As with competency-based learning, the challenge is getting subject matter experts to also become instructional design experts, or having them work with instructional design experts to revamp their courses. Both options pose resource and inertia issues.



Lastly, I question the value of the proposition of providing credit for on-the-job learning. This is already something that is occurring, and it something integral to providing services to clients, so why do we need to get credit for it? CPAs who are committed to excellence will both ensure that they and their staff are learning on-the-job, and increasing their competence—getting credit for it won’t necessarily increase their competence, and again those that aren’t will find ways to cheat the system.



Is a Shift to Competency-based Credits Really Necessary?



I left the meeting unsure whether our actual compliance requirements had to change. Could we actually address the problems by simply enhancing current learning offerings through increasing the competency of the instructors and improving the design of the courses?



Firms that want to differentiate themselves, both to their clients and their staff (including potential staff), will want to use a competency-based model for both professional development and performance evaluations. This however will require that their HR departments (who are often recruiting and compliance-focused) become more competent in organizational development.



Smaller firms will not be able to do this on their own. I believe this provides a big opportunity for the CPA firm-related associations (state societies, firm alliances, and firm networks) to provide these services to their members. The AICPA has also already provided a competency framework for its Chartered Global Management (CGMA) credential that can be used by accountants working within finance and managerial accounting roles in their organizations.



Opportunities abound with the shift to a competency-based model within the accounting profession. Whether a regulatory change needs to occur to force the adoption of this model within the accounting profession remains to be seen.





This post was originally published on the Improving the World by Inspiring Accountants blog.





18 comments

Leave a comment
  1. Sanctus | Jul 20, 2018

    Hii.. your blog is very nice and impresseive, wanna know more about it and keep updating us like this...it’s really helpful for everyone.

    Beard regrowth serum
    Qraa beard vitalizer
    Beard regrowth
    Beard serum

  2. Global | Jul 20, 2018

    Thanks for sharing nice blog it’s really helpful for everyone.This blog is so nice to me. I will keep on coming here again and again.

    B.ed admission
    admission in b tech
    LLB from ccs
    m.ed admission 2018

  3. ales | Jul 19, 2018

    Temgean refers to and is derived from TEMporary service Economy Amongst Nations. With an ERC20 token capped at only 10 billion, Temgean coin provides a means of payment and exchange amongst people from different background involved in the service economy. The global service economy is estimated at USD2.2 trillion annually and it represents services from Accounting, Construction Workers, Caregivers, Event Planners, Hotel Workers, Tour Guide, IT Support, Physiotherapist Personal Trainers, Nannies, Electrician, Housekeeping, Social Workers etc. The opportunities associated with the service economy for forward and backward integration is huge.

    Ethereum

  4. Steven Smith | Jul 19, 2018
    I like this website and me also RE magazine reader. It is always fantastic and full of nice information. college statistics help
  5. James Smith | Jul 18, 2018
    Really I appreciate this article made to share the knowledge. This is really a great stuff for sharing. Dissertation help
  6. maes | Jul 17, 2018

    You can buy followers, likes, video views, retweets, comments and reviews, not only for Facebook and Instagram but also for the social networks twitter, YouTube, Google plus and Pinterest. Facebook emoticons likes are also becoming more and more popular and give your mail an optical eye-catcher. For all offers discretion, anonymity, 100% safe and without password, we distribute our products to you at a fair price.

    buy followers

  7. maes | Jul 17, 2018

    Here you get a fast and high Instagram reach. It works with HQlike plus, the marketing experts ensure that you get the agreed amount of Instagram followers on your account within a very short time. Due to the special quality of the followers you only get real and high-quality Instagram followers on your profile. Option HQ plus is for followers who not only look at your posts, but also like and comment. These are really Instagram followers who are great and highly recommended.

    Instagram followers

  8. ales | Jul 14, 2018

    I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog

    Ukrayna Harkov Karazin Üniversitesi

  9. maes | Jul 14, 2018

    Is it okay to post part of this on my website basically post a hyperlink to this webpage?

    Ukrayna Sumy Üniversitesi

  10. afl | Jul 14, 2018

    Love to peruse your posts… . 

    Ukrayna Kiev Havacılık Üniversitesi

  11. madfe | Jul 14, 2018

    IPAYTOTAL is focused on providing comprehensive and affordable travel merchant accounts for our clients.IPAYTOTAL works with a variety of payment processors who provide Best Travel Merchant accounts and acquiring banks that allow travel agencies to process credit cards. We pride ourselves in providing reliable, affordable and secure merchant account services for travel agencies all around the world.

    travel industry merchant accounts

  12. maes | Jul 12, 2018

    These sorts of page sections keeps up the general open vitality on the site, and keep molding somewhat more 

    voyance sans cb

  13. mas | Jul 12, 2018

    Hi I am so pleased I found your blog, 

    Ukrayna Kiev Taras Shevchenko Üniversitesi

  14. mas | Jul 11, 2018

    هل تبحث عن مواقع اعلانات مجانية مبوبة؟ موقع اسواق العراق، موقع متميز لنشر الإعلانات المجانية في العراق. قم بزيارة موقعنا وانشر اعلانك مجانا. اتصل بنا لمزيد من المعلومات. 

    عقار للبيع في العراق

  15. whoisname | Jul 07, 2018
    <a href="nytimes.com">New York Times</a>
    https://www.nytimes.com
  16. martin garix | Jul 02, 2018
    Hello users here the most important information to all window users,so guys firstly update your window,Microsoft update a new feature in window 10 windows 10 microsoft it is the best version and microsoft announced window 10 is a last version.
  17. Elvena | Jun 25, 2018
    Professional education is something that we all need to get for australian writings so that we can work on it and we can know what is missing here and there. Please tell me more about it.
  18. AidaAddison | Jun 22, 2018
    Everyone should read "Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry into the Value of Work" by Matthew Crawford essay writer. He makes a very clear case for working with your hands in ways that engage your mind. This is not for being on an assembly line. This is for building, designing, repairing, diagnosing, really engaging in analysis and study of the task "at hand". This brings together so many more ways of thinking and evaluating and synthesizing than any desk job could possibly accomplish. 

    Leave a comment

    Donny Shimamoto
    About the Author

    Donny Shimamoto, CPA.CITP, CGMA, is a member of the CPA Center of Excellence® Advisory Board. This board is comprised of experts who are guiding strategy on the future of learning, competency-based education and emerging technologies. Shimamoto is the founder and managing director of IntrapriseTechKnowlogies LLC, an advisory-focused CPA firm. He has been influential in several AICPA initiatives including developing an IT Competency Model for CPAs and the redesign of the CITP credential. Contact Donny Shimamoto at donny@intaprise.us.

    Learn More